Skip to main content

Table 2 Results of univariate meta-regressions for the 13 studies of cognitive behaviour therapy

From: Brief psychological therapies for anxiety and depression in primary care: meta-analysis and meta-regression

Variable

Category 1 (k; N)

Category 2 (k; N)

Regression coefficient

Standard error

95% CI

P*

I 2

Adj R 2

Dichotomous

        

Diagnosis (model a)

Anxiety = 0 (7; 497)

Depression = 1 (4; 275)

.72

.20

.28-1.16

.005

0%

91%

Diagnosis (model b)

Anxiety = 0 (7; 497)

Mixed anxiety & depression = 1 (2, 479)

.80

.18

.36-1.23

.003

2%

94%

Diagnosis (model c)

Depression = 0 (4; 275)

Mixed anxiety & depression = 1 (2; 479)

.07

.17

-.39-.53

.70

0%

0%

Country

UK = 0 (12; 1214)

Other = 1 (1; 37)

.36

.56

-.87-1.58

1.00

71%

0%

Type of data

Continuous = 0 (9; 931)

Dichotomous = 1 (4; 320)

-.11

.31

-.79-.58

1.00

70%

0%

Continuous

Range ( k ; N )

      

Number of sessions

3.7-9.8 (13; 1251)

-.03

.08

-.21-.15

1.00

65%

0%

Follow up (weeks)

4-31.6 (13; 1251)

.03

.02

-.003-.07

.46

67%

22%

Year of publication

1982-2004 (13; 1251)

-.02

.02

-.06-.02

.89

59%

16%

Number randomized

20-429 (13; 1251)

.001

.001

-.001-.004

.89

59%

7%

Attrition (intervention group)

0-37% (13; 1251)

-.01

.01

-.03-.02

1.00

67%

0%

Attrition (control group)

0-33% (13; 1251)

-.01

.01

-.04-.03

1.00

67%

0%

Study quality

1-4 (13, 1251)

.16

.22

-.31-.64

1.00

71%

0%

  1. *P-values are adjusted for multiple testing, calculated using the Higgins and Thompson Monte Carlo permutation test (10,000 permutations), except for the diagnostic variables which are unadjusted.
  2. Adj R 2 = adjusted R 2 (proportion of between-study variance explained by the covariate); k = number of studies; N = total sample size.