Strategy | Costs per 100,000 people (CNY, thousand) | Incremental cost per 100,000 people (CNY, thousand) | QALYs per 100,000 people | Incremental QALYs per 100,000 people | ICER (CNY/QALY) | iNMB | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vs the status quo strategy | Vs the strategy preceding it on the efficiency frontier | Vs the status quo strategy | Vs the strategy preceding it on the efficiency frontier | Vs the status quo strategy | Vs the strategy preceding it on the efficiency frontier | ||||
No screening | 845,168 | − 434,090 | NA | 1,150,366 | − 3235 | NA | Dominated | NA | − 3518 |
H1-MHnone-LMnone-Lnone | 924,335 | − 354,923 | 79,167 | 1,151,147 | − 2453 | 781 | Dominated | 101,309 | − 2411 |
H1-MHone-off-LMone-off-Lnone | 947,457 | − 331,801 | 102,289 | 1,151,200 | − 2400 | 834 | Dominated | 122,594 | − 2513 |
H1-MHone-off-LMone-off-Lone-off | 958,602 | − 320,655 | 113,434 | 1,151,202 | − 2398 | 837 | Dominated | 135,567 | − 2619 |
H1-MHone-off-LMnone-Lnone | 937,823 | − 341,434 | 92,656 | 1,151,247 | − 2354 | 881 | Dominated | 105,176 | − 2304 |
H1-MH3-LMone-off-Lnone | 999,095 | − 280,162 | 153,928 | 1,152,081 | − 1520 | 1715 | Dominated | 89,762 | − 891 |
H1-MH3-LMone-off-Lone-off | 1,010,241 | − 269,017 | 165,073 | 1,152,083 | − 1518 | 1717 | Dominated | 96,129 | − 997 |
H1-MH3-LMnone-Lnonea | 989,462 | − 289,795 | 144,295 | 1,152,127 | − 1473 | 1761 | Dominated | 81,919 | − 681 |
H1-MH2-LM3-Lnone | 1,041,867 | − 237,391 | 52,405 | 1,152,229 | − 1372 | 101 | Dominated | 517,113 | − 959 |
H1-MH2-LMone-off-Lnone | 1,018,091 | − 261,166 | 28,629 | 1,152,258 | − 1343 | 131 | Dominated | 218,734 | − 650 |
H1-MH2-LMone-off-Lone-off | 1,029,237 | − 250,021 | 39,774 | 1,152,260 | − 1340 | 133 | Dominated | 298,492 | − 755 |
H1-MH1-LM1-Lnone | 1,123,224 | − 156,033 | 133,762 | 1,152,277 | − 1323 | 150 | Dominated | 891,217 | − 1654 |
H1-MH2-LMnone-Lnonea | 1,008,458 | − 270,799 | 18,996 | 1,152,305 | − 1296 | 177 | Dominated | 107,036 | − 440 |
H1-MH1-LMone-off-Lnone | 1,047,048 | − 232,210 | 38,590 | 1,152,354 | − 1247 | 49 | Dominated | 781,869 | − 706 |
H1-MH1-LMone-off-Lone-off | 1,058,193 | − 221,064 | 49,735 | 1,152,356 | − 1244 | 52 | Dominated | 961,581 | − 812 |
H1-MH1-LM2-Lnone | 1,090,559 | − 188,698 | 82,101 | 1,152,357 | − 1243 | 53 | Dominated | 1,553,900 | − 1133 |
H1-MH1-LMnone-Lnone | 1,037,415 | − 241,843 | 28,957 | 1,152,401 | − 1200 | 96 | Dominated | 301,814 | − 497 |
H1-MH3-LM3-Lnone | 1,039,447 | − 239,810 | 30,989 | 1,152,411 | − 1190 | 106 | Dominated | 291,936 | − 492 |
H1-MH3-LM3-Lone-off | 1,050,593 | − 228,665 | 42,135 | 1,152,413 | − 1187 | 109 | Dominated | 388,277 | − 598 |
H1-MH2-LM3-Lone-off | 1,069,589 | − 209,669 | 61,131 | 1,152,591 | − 1010 | 286 | Dominated | 213,752 | − 357 |
H1-MH2-LM2-Lnone | 1,078,179 | − 201,079 | 69,721 | 1,152,621 | − 979 | 317 | Dominated | 220,186 | − 368 |
H1-MH2-LM2-Lone-off | 1,089,324 | − 189,933 | 80,866 | 1,152,624 | − 977 | 319 | Dominated | 253,490 | − 474 |
H1-MH1-LM1-Lone-off | 1,150,946 | − 128,312 | 142,488 | 1,152,639 | − 961 | 335 | Dominated | 425,672 | − 1052 |
H1-MH1-LM3-Lnone | 1,087,400 | − 191,858 | 78,942 | 1,152,684 | − 916 | 380 | Dominated | 207,980 | − 308 |
H1-MH1-LM3-Lone-off | 1,098,545 | − 180,712 | 90,087 | 1,152,687 | − 914 | 382 | Dominated | 235,874 | − 413 |
H1-MH1-LM2-Lone-off | 1,118,281 | − 160,977 | 109,823 | 1,152,720 | − 881 | 415 | Dominated | 264,663 | − 530 |
H1-MH3-LM3-L3a | 1,114,292 | − 164,966 | 105,834 | 1,153,247 | − 354 | 942 | Dominant | 112,300 | 791 |
H1-MH2-LM3-L3a | 1,133,288 | − 145,970 | 18,996 | 1,153,425 | − 176 | 177 | Dominant | 107,036 | 1032 |
H1-MH2-LM2-L3 | 1,153,023 | − 126,234 | 38,731 | 1,153,458 | − 143 | 33 | Dominant | 1,172,851 | 915 |
H1-MH1-LM1-L3 | 1,214,645 | − 64,613 | 100,353 | 1,153,473 | − 127 | 49 | Dominant | 2,058,604 | 337 |
H1-MH1-LM3-L3 | 1,162,244 | − 117,013 | 47,952 | 1,153,520 | − 80 | 96 | Dominant | 499,807 | 975 |
H1-MH1-LM2-L3 | 1,181,980 | − 97,277 | 67,688 | 1,153,554 | − 47 | 129 | Dominant | 524,855 | 858 |
H1-MH2-LM2-L2a | 1,177,849 | − 101,409 | 63,557 | 1,153,596 | − 5 | 171 | Dominant | 371,625 | 1002 |
H1-MH1-LM1-L1 (status quo strategy) | 1,279,258 | NA | 101,409 | 1,153,601 | NA | 5 | NA | 20,062,309 | NA |
H1-MH1-LM1-L2 | 1,239,470 | − 39,787 | 61,622 | 1,153,611 | 11 | 16 | Cost-saving | 3,918,770 | 424 |
H1-MH1-LM2-L2a | 1,206,805 | − 72,452 | 28,957 | 1,153,692 | 91 | 96 | Cost-saving | 301,814 | 945 |